Hi everyone, this is the first time I'm GMing a Mutants and Mastermind game (in fact, it's the first time I'm GMing/DMing period), and I'm a little confused on something I can't quite find in the heroes handbook. One of my players is making a character with Cosmic based powers, and he took the Cosmic Blast power from the 3e Cosmic Power Profile (Ranged Damage). He took 10 ranks in it, and also has 2 ranks of Ranged Attack 2 and a total of 7 ranks (including ability modifiers) of Ranged Combat: Energy. So my question(s) are this:
1) Does this actually give him a 19 bonus in attack bonus when using this power, essentially turning the check into a d20 + 19 vs DC? This seems ridiculously high to me as a first time GM, and provides extremely little room for him to actually miss.
and
2) Is "Energy" too broad of a category for the Ranged Combat skill? Should I have him trim it down to a skill for each of his ranged attacks?
First Time GM Questions 3e - Attack Checks
-
- Bystander
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 7:26 am
Re: First Time GM Questions 3e - Attack Checks
Flying Cobra actually made a quick cheat sheet for things like this. Check this thread.
To address your specific issue, you need to remember that almost all attack come in two parts: the Attack check, which tells whether or not the attack hits; and the Effect check, which gives how much the attack affects the target.
For the Cosmic Blast, the 2 ranks of Ranged Attack 2 and 7 ranks (including ability modifiers) of Ranged Combat: Energy would add up to +9 to Attack. The 10 ranks of Range Damage is the Effect.
In combat, he would roll an Attack check as d20 + 9 vs DC10 + the defender's Dodge rank, since it's a ranged attack. If the attack check succeeds, the defender would the roll a resistance check as d20 + defender's Toughness vs DC15 + the attacker's Effect (in this case 10 ranks of Cosmic Blast).
As for the "Ranged Combat: Energy" question, it depends on how broadly he can apply the bonus. If the attacks are a relatively tight group of attacks, it should be fine. Without seeing the sheet, I would assume he has several powers in an array, and if the bonus only applies to attacks in that array, that's a reasonable limit. He wouldn't be able to, say, pick up a villain's drop ray gun and use that extra +7 to hit.
To address your specific issue, you need to remember that almost all attack come in two parts: the Attack check, which tells whether or not the attack hits; and the Effect check, which gives how much the attack affects the target.
For the Cosmic Blast, the 2 ranks of Ranged Attack 2 and 7 ranks (including ability modifiers) of Ranged Combat: Energy would add up to +9 to Attack. The 10 ranks of Range Damage is the Effect.
In combat, he would roll an Attack check as d20 + 9 vs DC10 + the defender's Dodge rank, since it's a ranged attack. If the attack check succeeds, the defender would the roll a resistance check as d20 + defender's Toughness vs DC15 + the attacker's Effect (in this case 10 ranks of Cosmic Blast).
As for the "Ranged Combat: Energy" question, it depends on how broadly he can apply the bonus. If the attacks are a relatively tight group of attacks, it should be fine. Without seeing the sheet, I would assume he has several powers in an array, and if the bonus only applies to attacks in that array, that's a reasonable limit. He wouldn't be able to, say, pick up a villain's drop ray gun and use that extra +7 to hit.
Sorry, I can't hear your argument for realism over the sound of my eye beams. 
My original characters thread (2e)
My League of Legends conversion thread (3e)
My Rules Musings in 3e

My original characters thread (2e)
My League of Legends conversion thread (3e)
My Rules Musings in 3e
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests